An insidious company I used to trust
It all started 6 months ago when I went to write an email from my phone (something I rarely have the need to do). During the course of it, Gmail AI "tools" kept "helpfully" suggesting changes to my email that made my writing boring, generic, and less precise. It made me so angry, I immediately decided to switch everything to a Proton account I had made years ago, but never did anything with. My disdain for Google had been increasing as the years go by. Their wonton disrespect for personal privacy and insidious inclusion of AI in everything has been making me less and less trusting of them. This was the catalyst needed to fully kick off the effort to transition away (that and spite).
This turned out to be a greater headache than I thought, and 6 months later I'm still working on transitioning everything over to my new account. It wasn't hard, per se, but Google sure does go through great lengths to make transitioning away incredibly difficult. I figured I'd take this opportunity to describe the difficulties and changes I needed to make in my life to properly transition.
The first step was setting up forwarding from Gmail to the new email account. This was easy; all I had to do was edit the forwarding settings and all was complete. The real trick was every new email I got I had to update the contact information for the company I received the email from (I rarely, if ever, receive personal emails). That part was actually kind of enjoyable because it made me reassess if I actually needed to be getting emails from that company and/or if I wanted to entirely delete my account. Even now I find myself randomly needing to update my email address. I imagine this will be an ongoing struggle for the next few years.
Photos
Next was photos. Folks, let me tell you: Google does not want you downloading your own photos. They have an entirely separate service called Google Takeout that is used for "helpfully" exporting your data. It is slow, confusing, obtuse, and needlessly complex. I had over 10 years of photos to download. Google doesn't let you, just, get all the data in one download (which makes sense because you don't want to be dealing with an enormous file that can easily fail). Instead, you request the data you want (from a list of all 10 gazillion Google services), wait until they email you telling you the data is ready, and you're finally allowed to download the chunked data. For me, that resulted in twenty, 2 GB zip files. However, downloading these files from Google Takeout was incredibly slow. It's almost as if they were intentionally using the slowest possible server to provide the data. They also only let you have access to those files for 7 days. After which, you would need to re-request your data.
So, I had to quickly (within 7 days) download all 20 zips. These would regularly fail and took hours for each one. I found it easiest to kick off a batch of downloads at bedtime, and then retry the one or two that would inevitably fail overnight in the morning. I eventually was able to get all the files, but it was quite the headache. Then was the painstaking effort of uploading the photos to Proton Drive. This was also painfully slow. I found it easiest to kick off a batch of photos while I was working, check back in an hour, and do another batch. The entire effort of downloading, unzipping, and re-uploading my photos took the good part of 5 days of background effort.
All in all this was the most painful effort, and it really shows how difficult it is even for someone who knows what they're doing to move away from Google Photos. I try to gauge difficulty as compared to if my mom could do this. Do either of my parents know what a zip file is or how to unzip them? Could they have gotten the files from the separate Google Takeout service with the obtuse user interface? Do they know how to re-upload them to a separate service? The answer to most/all of these questions is "no"; the average user would not be able to easily do this.
Drive
I was also paying Google $3 a month for an extra 250 GB of cloud storage. After cancelling, I immediately got a warning that Google Drive would cease to operate properly until I had reduced my data usage to under 15 GB. This was significantly easier to manage than Google Photos. I would pick a folder of data to download, download it, delete the folder from Google Drive, then re-upload those files to Proton Drive.
I immediately began to realize I had gobs of unnecessary files from years ago I would likely never need again. As of this writing, I've successfully transferred enough of my data to Proton Drive such that I'm not in violation of Google's data usage policies, but I most certainly would be able to delete half, if not more, of the files I did transfer over to Proton Drive; something to look into on a lazy Sunday.
But now Proton may also suck?
A few weeks ago 404 Media reported that the CEO of Proton was fully convinced that AI was the panacea for everything and trying to force the company in a more AI-focused direction. This is, of course, incredibly disheartening. I moved away from Google due to the heavy focus on AI-branded products. I'm more interested in supporting companies that write actually quality software instead of those that are convinced that AI actually produces value.
At this current moment I'm not really sure what to do. I've already spent the greater part of 6 months transferring all my data and accounts to Proton under the assumption that the company was producing a quality product. Now it seems that might not be the case, and I'm caught in a dilemma once again.
For now, I'm not willing to begin another transfer to some other company. I can only hope that things change at Proton otherwise I'm going to have to go through this entire nightmare process again.
Tags
- ← Previous
Behold a blog